Ok, it’s true, I don’t DIY. Most of the time. But last year, come Valentine’s Day, Big’s teacher insisted on homemade valentines with no candy. While I liked the idea in spirit, I was desperate. I was newly in love with Pinterest (before she made me look like a fool), and searched like crazy for boy friendly Valentine’s ideas. There were some fun superhero ones, but Big really wanted to make footballs.
So, I risked my sanity and my children’s safety, and headed to the local craft store. After some shopping, here’s what we came up with — something that was actually kind of cool. (Cool enough for me to Pin, that is.) Please note, this was the sample one I made the night before we embarked on the adventure together. As a kindergartener with a short attention span and a bizarre disregard for following traced lines, his did not look much like this. But I accidentally (sort of) forgot to take a picture.
You’ll need:
brown foam sheets (qty depends on size of Valentine & number you’re making)
white yarn
plastic needle
white or silver pen (might want to ask for a good suggestion at the craft store, I bought a few and found a silver metallic worked well)
heavy stock paper/thin cardboard
wine (color does not matter)
Here’s how I suggest making them (some of which we actually did):
1) Trace a mini football on heavy stock paper/thin cardboard to create the template. If you don’t have one, come borrow one of the 3, 256 we have. Cut out the template, then trace it onto the foam sheets. (You’ll need 2 footballs per Valentine.)

2) Have your child cut out all the footballs. (This may require you to have a glass of wine of three so that you’re not cringing at the horrifically jagged edges that result.)
3) Have your child write notes on the bottom 1/2 of the footballs (in case their eager stitches sneak further down than mine did). If they want to get creative (which Big absolutely did not want to do), they can write things like, “You’re a winner!” or “I scored having you for a friend.” or “You’re a catch!” (The wine may help you here…I’m drinking decaf tea as I write this.)

4) Help your child thread the needle, then let them stitch a few stitches along the top of a “cover” football and a football with a note on it. (Big wrote his after they were stitched and it was a bit tricky. Actually being left handed and using smeary pens is tricky no matter what…)

5) Send ’em off to school and hope that the class recognizes them as footballs, not another unfriendly brown object.
Just in case footballs aren’t your thing, these were a few cute Valentines other kids in the class made. (In case I did such a good job you can’t tell, I’ve used my Photoshop skills to block out the names so no other moms kids in the class get credit for having a cooler idea than me Big.)




these are totally AWESOME!!!!!! well done, Amy! 🙂
On our end, Finn was dead set on these space invader pins I found at Michael’s for Valentine’s day (I’m also anti-candy for v-day and try to do something else as a fun add on to the card) so I’ve been trying to come up with a clever saying to go into each one… we’ll see what I end up with!
but again – VERY IMPRESSED with your creation! VERY pinterest worthy!! 🙂
Wow, sounds like you have your work cut out for you. You, my friend, are the DIY queen! Thanks for the Pin-y love!
Love this! Thanks!!!